user preferences

New Events

Mashriq / Arabia / Iraq

no event posted in the last week

Controversy over 'anti-semitism' and FdCA statement

category mashriq / arabia / iraq | imperialism / war | other libertarian press author Monday January 05, 2009 19:16author by Anarkismo Editorial group Report this post to the editors

These was an extensive controversy on Anarkismo over one small section of the FdCA statement on Gaza. This thread preserves the discussion of this which has been moved from the original thread as its no longer relevant to that thread.

Re-wording of statement

The statement originally published contained a grave error in wording and, while it was a minor part of the statement as a whole, gave rise to some controversy. This error has now been rectified.

Nestor McNab
for FdCA International Relations



The paragraph which was changed originally read
"As far as the USA is concerned, there is no doubt. Apart from the important strategic and territorial alliance that Israel represents for American imperialism in the Middle East, it also has to deal with the powerful US Jewish economic lobby, which is strong enough to bring about a stong influence on US foreign policy. And what is happening today comes across as a clear warning to the president-elect, Obama."

In the corrected version of the statement (see http://www.anarkismo.net/article/11133 ) it reads
"Apart from the important strategic and territorial alliance that Israel represents for American imperialism in the Middle East, it also has to deal with the powerful US pro-Israel lobby, which is strong enough to bring about a strong influence on US foreign policy. And what is happening today comes across as a clear warning to the president-elect, Obama."

The comments below are obviously the discussion on the first version.

Related Link: http://www.anarkismo.net/article/11133

 #   Title   Author   Date 
 47   Mearsheimer & Walt's view rebutted     nestor    Sat Jan 17, 2009 04:30 
 46   Olmert's claims revive specter of "Israel Lobby"     José Antonio Gutiérrez D.    Fri Jan 16, 2009 23:30 
 45   Arguing about facts is counter productive.     Ilan S.    Tue Jan 06, 2009 23:46 
 44   Learning from errors     mitch    Tue Jan 06, 2009 21:34 
 43   Some thoughts...     Redboots    Tue Jan 06, 2009 21:07 
 42   Oops - new text     Anna    Tue Jan 06, 2009 18:01 
 41   Don't like it.     Anna    Tue Jan 06, 2009 17:36 
 40   Good move     Laure Akai    Tue Jan 06, 2009 07:18 
 39   AF statement?     Mick    Tue Jan 06, 2009 07:14 
 38   Sectarianism     andrew    Tue Jan 06, 2009 05:13 
 37   re:Andrew/AF statement     Django    Mon Jan 05, 2009 03:41 
 36   Abandonment of class politics     Steven.    Mon Jan 05, 2009 03:25 
 35   edit     888    Mon Jan 05, 2009 02:33 
 34   storm in a teacup     888    Mon Jan 05, 2009 02:25 
 33   AF statement?     mick    Mon Jan 05, 2009 02:23 
 32   re: Django     andrew    Mon Jan 05, 2009 01:56 
 31   Response to Alan's Misunderstanding     Rogue    Mon Jan 05, 2009 01:53 
 30   Middle Ground     thugarchist    Mon Jan 05, 2009 01:37 
 29   re: Andrew     Django    Mon Jan 05, 2009 01:36 
 28   re: knightrose     andrew    Mon Jan 05, 2009 01:07 
 27   The "Zionist lobby"     jhaaglund    Mon Jan 05, 2009 01:07 
 26   That's ridiculous     Alan    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:59 
 25   In which case...     Alan    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:56 
 24   it all depends on the context     knightrose    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:55 
 23   Changing     andrew    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:55 
 22   ...     d    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:51 
 21   hmm     d    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:48 
 20   Why is this complicated?     Rogue    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:36 
 19   um..     still shocked    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:36 
 18   Explain     Andrew    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:22 
 17   Well...     shocked    Mon Jan 05, 2009 00:04 
 16   Sectarian because ..     andrew    Sun Jan 04, 2009 23:55 
 15   ?     Django    Sun Jan 04, 2009 23:40 
 14   poor wording taken out of context     Mick    Sun Jan 04, 2009 23:35 
 13   hardly "sectarian"     Django    Sun Jan 04, 2009 23:34 
 12   ...     d    Sun Jan 04, 2009 23:22 
 11   ???     d    Sun Jan 04, 2009 23:20 
 10   Clarification     Class Struggle    Sun Jan 04, 2009 23:09 
   Retreat     andrew    Sun Jan 04, 2009 22:48 
   High Jewcount     jhaaglund    Sun Jan 04, 2009 22:23 
   Facts are not always nice.     Ilan Shalif    Sun Jan 04, 2009 22:12 
   Sectarian     Andrew    Sun Jan 04, 2009 22:12 
   In reply to Andrew     jhaaglund    Sun Jan 04, 2009 22:01 
   Depressing     andrew    Sun Jan 04, 2009 21:50 
   jokers...     a/c militant    Sun Jan 04, 2009 21:39 
   Conspiracy theory     Steven.    Sun Jan 04, 2009 20:55 
   Jews control american policy?     Django    Sun Jan 04, 2009 20:34 


Number of comments per page
  
 
This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch
E

Latest News

Mashriq / Arabia / Iraq | Imperialism / War | en

Mon 20 May, 02:43

browse text browse image

textPalestine-Israel, Some activities the Anarchists Against the Wall initiative involved with lately 17:23 Tue 15 Feb by Ilan S. 0 comments

textIraqi trade union leader on the current situation in Iraq 20:28 Wed 03 Oct by Manuel Baptista 0 comments

textIsrael: "Occupation 40" - first actions in Tel Aviv 16:48 Wed 06 Jun by Ilan Shalif 1 comments

text6 days of protests to mark 40 years of occupation 18:50 Tue 05 Jun by Kibush 40 0 comments

textItaly: "Resistance, disobedience, solidarity" - an evening with an Israeli refusni 17:09 Tue 21 Nov by FdCA Fano 0 comments

textIsrael, Direct action near the border of Gaza Strip 01:29 Sun 19 Nov by Ilan S. 0 comments

text655,000 Dead in Iraq since Invasion 17:23 Fri 13 Oct by Anarcho 0 comments

textStatement on al-Badil article 16:51 Mon 11 Sep by Alternative Libertaire 0 comments

textLebanon- The Smoke, Anguish and Terror of a Fascist Attack 21:28 Sat 02 Sep by Pieman Paydar 1 comments

textOn the slaughter in the Middle East 13:33 Sat 19 Aug by Federation of Anarchists of Greece (OAE) - Press Group 19 comments

more >>

Opinion and Analysis

image1st of May is the day of class struggle & resistance against the militia and the State’s war in Iraq May 03 by Kurdistan Anarchist Forum 0 comments

imageA Close look at the Syrian revolution Nov 06 by A Syrian comrade 3 comments

imageImperial Echoes - The Salvador Option in Iraq Nov 05 by dara 0 comments

imagePalestine: No State Solution Aug 25 by Melbourne Anarchist Communist Group 0 comments

imageCall for An Anarchist Manifesto about Palestine Apr 20 by Mazen Kamalmaz 9 comments

more >>

Press Releases

text6 days of protests to mark 40 years of occupation Jun 05 0 comments

textStatement on al-Badil article Sep 11 AL 0 comments

textLebanon- The Smoke, Anguish and Terror of a Fascist Attack Sep 02 Grupo Qhispikay Llaqta, Perú 1 comments

textOn the slaughter in the Middle East Aug 19 Anarkismo 19 comments

textNews from Lebanon : the Israeli attack Jul 30 (Libertarian Communist Alternative) 11 comments

more >>
© 2005-2013 Anarkismo.net. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Anarkismo.net. [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]