user preferences

Recent articles by Gerardo Otero and Efe Can Gürcan
This author has not submitted any other articles.
Recent Articles about International Miscellaneous

Επαναστατικ^... Mar 11 17 by Dimitri (republ.)

H έννοια της φύ... Jan 01 17 by Έλενα Νακοπούλου 

The Crisis of European Integration and the Challenges for the Left Oct 25 16 by Panagiotis Sotiris

Arab Spring and Syrian Refugee Crisis: Ten Theses for Discussion

category international | miscellaneous | non-anarchist press author Wednesday November 18, 2015 16:26author by Gerardo Otero and Efe Can Gürcan - The Bullet Report this post to the editors

Our goal is to formulate ten theses on what we believe constitutes the historical background of the Syrian refugee crisis within the context of the Arab Spring. One central argument is that Western meddling in this process was turned into a violent contest for state power that has resulted in grave human tragedy. The recent Paris attacks with over 100 fatalities – resulting in a state-of-emergency declaration and arson of refugee camps in retaliation – indicate that the Syrian refugee crisis has already taken on a greater importance for global politics.

1. The Arab Spring was initially a hopeful phenomenon of social mobilization against authoritarian regimes. It started in December 2010 in Tunisia, with mobilized working class and civic organizations after the self-immolation of a street vendor repressed by police forces. Social mobilization became so vigorous that the president had to resign after three weeks.

2. Similar mobilizations began to take place in several Middle Eastern and North African countries including Egypt, Libya and Syria, but in each of these nations the degree of civil-society organization was different and the extent of meddling by Western powers also varied considerably.

Egypt: Elections and Coup d’État

3. In Egypt the most mobilized sectors of civil society were not the most organized. The Muslim Brotherhood, a latecomer into the protests, capitalized the process that ultimately resulted in the downfall of Hosni Mubarak. The military was a very strong institution with deep-seated economic interests. Mubarak became a sacrificial lamb in lieu of pacification. A negotiated transition to electoral democracy led not to the triumph of the mobilized liberal and socialist elements in civil society but, to electing the Muslim Brotherhood's candidate. Coupled with serious economic adversities, Mohamed Morsi's presidency aroused widespread controversies on the Islamization of society, and was met with mass protests attended by millions. Eventually, the Muslim Brotherhood experience ended in tragedy, as the military decided to stop the Islamist impositions by his administration in just over a year. With considerable popular support, the July 2013 coup d’état restored military rule, albeit with more authoritarian undertones than even during Mubarak's time. Geopolitically, the new regime seems to pursue balance between Russia and the United States. Despite its friendly relationships with Russia, Egypt's military involvement beside the Saudis in Yemen would certainly contribute to the further destabilization of the region.

4. Libya's case was very different immediately after the first social protests and mobilizations: elements from Muammar Gaddafi's army presumably joined the protests, which became an excuse for his regime to respond with violent repression. Western powers then became heavily involved through a “no fly zone” ultimately resulting in the killing of Gaddafi. Western-supported mercenaries were involved and eventually transferred to Syria. There were no significant groups organized in civil society, with much of its rural population structured along tribal lines. The 2012 radical-Islamist attack on the U.S. Consulate and CIA operators in Benghazi set off the civil war in which Libya continues to be mired, with tens of thousands of casualties.

5. Other Arab countries saw uprisings that were repressed quickly. But Syria's uprising turned into a violent civil war since 2011, which was indeed facilitated by the authoritarian nature of the Syrian state. More complex and capitalistically developed than Libya, Syria has international allegiances with Iran, Russia and China. The persistence of Syria's allies has prevented an all-out intervention by Western powers led by the United States, the United Kingdom and France. Their intervention has been by proxy, by supporting supposedly “moderate” opponents of the Bashar al-Assad regime. But non-Syrian radical Islamists who have become bolder since the U.S. invasion of and war against Iraq have become a nearly dominant presence in Syria. Many of their leaders also fought in Libya. The Western-supported proxy war was met with the military involvement of Iran and Russia, at the request of the Assad regime, which further escalated the conflict situation. The ultimate three-way stalemate after four and a half years of civil war has caused the displacement of about 11 million Syrians, both internally and internationally, representing more than half the total population. About 250,000 have lost their lives.

Intervention and Migrant/Refugee Debate

6. Had there been no Western intervention in Syria, there would be no refugee crisis in 2015. Indeed, Turkey's active involvement should not be underestimated. Consequently, over four million Syrians have left their country since 2012. Most have taken refuge in the surrounding countries, namely Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. But a growing number are moving on to the European Union. How to deal with this exceptionally large number of refugees has divided governments and people in the European Union. The overt discussion is framed in terms of refugees and a humanitarian response, as if the human exodus were a problem in itself. Ultimately, however, this discussion roughly replicates traditional debates about migrants in general.

7. One question being raised is whether Syrian and other migrants are economic migrants or political refugees. The underlying assumption of this question is that political refugees are more deserving of asylum than economic migrants. But the fact is that all migrants that choose to leave their countries do so because their livelihoods are at stake. Granted, there are differing degrees of urgency, but how are destination countries to judge such nuance in an emergency? One of the Harper administration's questions was, for instance, whether the Syrian refugees owned a business prior to fleeing – this would make them more deserving in Canada: not a humanitarian but clearly a utilitarian criterion.

8. Two broad strands of interpretation in migration debates in advanced capitalist countries regard whether the effects of migrants focus on the countries of destination, or on sending countries, usually from developing societies. Countries of destination usually have a negative rate of natural population growth (i.e, less births than deaths), so they require new immigrants to sustain economic growth. But how to manage migration?

9. The liberal position welcomes migrants as they are expected to add to the labour force and cheapen the cost of labour. The nativist or xenophobic position opposes new immigrants, as is currently the case with Hungary and Poland, for example, in the European Union. More to the left of the political spectrum, migrants are welcome as long as they are guaranteed to enjoy the same labour rights as the rest of the labour force in the receiving nation. For the countries of origin, those sending the migrants, the challenge becomes that the basis for their sustainable development are being drained by out-migration of the young, better-educated and most entrepreneurial members of their societies.

10. In response to the Syrian crisis, the Canadian public opinion has been bombarded with a plethora of messages that encouraged donations and sponsorship for Syrian refugees. Such charity-centred and individualist solutions help nothing but distract the public opinion from the root causes of the problem, i.e. the U.S. unilateral interventionism. In the final analysis, the refugee crisis is merely the symptom of the real problem: the U.S. adventure to impose “democracy” in the Middle East and North Africa since 2003, with no regard for respecting national sovereignty. This is not only a contradiction in terms but also a tragic political, geopolitical and humanitarian failure. Beyond charity-centred and individualist solutions, the Canadian civil society needs to be mobilized to call for Syria's sovereignty as well as the USA and Canada's cooperation with Russia, as proposed by former Prime Minister Jean Chretien on 1 October 2015, as reported in the Globe and Mail. This would also benefit global peace and stability by reasserting the multipolar structure of the world. Three appropriate slogans are: Respect Syria's sovereignty, Respect multipolarity, Ask for Global Cooperation not a new cold war with Russia.

Related Link:
This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch

Front page

Aodhan Ó Ríordáin: Playing The Big Man in America

Nós anarquistas saudamos o 8 de março: dia internacional de luta e resistência das mulheres!

Özgürlüğümüz Mücadelemizdedir

IWD 2017: Celebrating a new revolution

Solidarité avec Théo et toutes les victimes des violences policières ! Non à la loi « Sécurité Publique » !

Solidaridad y Defensa de las Comunidades Frente al Avance del Paramilitarismo en el Cauca

A Conservative Threat Offers New Opportunities for Working Class Feminism

De las colectivizaciones al 15M: 80 años de lucha por la autogestión en España

False hope, broken promises: Obama’s belligerent legacy

Primer encuentro feminista Solidaridad – Federación Comunista Libertaria

Devrimci Anarşist Tutsak Umut Fırat Süvarioğulları Açlık Grevinin 39 Gününde

The Fall of Aleppo

Italia - Ricostruire opposizione sociale organizzata dal basso. Costruire un progetto collettivo per l’alternativa libertaria.

Recordando a César Roa, luchador de la caña

Prison Sentence to Managing Editor of Anarchist Meydan Newspaper in Turkey

Liberación de la Uma Kiwe, autonomía y territorio: una mirada libertaria para la comprensión de la lucha nasa

Misunderstanding syndicalism

American Anarchist and Wobbly killed by Turkey while fighting ISIS in Rojava

Devlet Tecavüzdür

Attaque fasciste sur la Croix Rousse et contre la librairie libertaire la Plume Noire

Red November, Black November – An Anarchist Response to the Election

Resistance at Standing Rock

1986-2016: 30° anniversario di Alternativa Libertaria/fdca

El feminismo es cuestión de vida o muerte

International | Miscellaneous | en

Mon 27 Mar, 08:49

browse text browse image

textPersonal statement on the Michael Schmidt affair: Lucien van der Walt, 11 February 2016 13:10 Fri 12 Feb by Lucien van der Walt 11 comments

Personal statement on the Michael Schmidt affair: Lucien van der Walt, 11 February 2016

zababooks.gif imagePublications by Zabalaza Books, March - June 2012 16:20 Thu 14 Jun by Zabalaza Books 0 comments

All new publications by Zabalaza Books from March till June 2012

An Anarchist Society imageNew Publications from Zabalaza Books 15:19 Mon 23 Jan by Zabalaza Books 0 comments

All new publications from Zabalaza Books for the month of January.

textFacebook page of 'Black Flame' reorganised and rebooted 20:16 Tue 13 Dec by Lucien van der Walt 0 comments

The Facebook page of 'Black Flame' has been reorganised and rebooted, now carrying regular updates related to the book by Lucien van der Walt and Michael Schmidt...

wayne_price.gif imageSeptember 2011 publications from Zabalaza Books 20:56 Mon 14 Nov by Zabalaza Books 0 comments

All publications from Zabalaza Books for the month of September

textBlog updated: Lucien van der Walt: writings on political economy, policy, unions and class struggles 23:27 Tue 18 Jan by Lucien van der Walt 0 comments

This blog has been updated again, collecting materials on strikes, union education, a recent "anarchist survey," the Spanish and Russian Revolutions, and race/ class in South Africa. The overall aim of the page is to collect my my writings on political economy, policy, unions and class struggles. These are are written from a red-and-black anarchist/ syndicalist perspective, and go back to the 1990s.

logo_zb_new.jpg imageNew releases from Zabalaza Books - November 2010 18:58 Thu 04 Nov by Griffin 0 comments

New additions to the Zabalaza Books site as of November 2010

textOn the suicide plane attack on the IRS offices in Austin 00:28 Sat 20 Feb by Gavin Gleeson 0 comments

Joe Stack recently committed suicide by crashing an airplane into the IRS offices in Austin, Texas. He left a manifesto describing the long path which had finally led him to this decision.

textBack issues of Black Flag go online 03:01 Tue 05 May by Rob Ray 0 comments

As Black Flag brings out it's May 2009 issue, we proudly present all three of the pre-2009 issues produced by the current collective, for free download from the website.

textAnnouncing the Institute for Anarchist Studies Web Site! 04:34 Sat 02 May by Cindy Milstein 0 comments

Dear Friends and Comrades,

The Institute for Anarchist Studies (IAS) has newly relaunched its Web site, now available at

more >>

imageThe Olympics: a reflection of society under capitalism Aug 16 by AWSM 0 comments

This article looks at what is wrong with the current nature of the Olympics.

imageWith the Working Class, Against Imperialism and Terror Attacks. Nov 15 by Lucien van der Walt 0 comments

Let us approach from the side of the struggle of working class and poor for freedom, and that means the struggle against all oppression and exploitation. From that side, be against imperialism, unconditionally, including whatever outrages the French state will now justify. But also be against reactionary anti-imperialists with reactionary programmes, and for a progressive anti-imperialism, like that of PKK in Rojava. The working class and left must lead anti-imperialist struggles, and work with progressive movements, including progressive anti-imperialists, to make a better world, pushing those struggles towards anarchist-communism.

imageBuild a Strong People: Latin American Lessons in Leadership Jan 08 by Jonathan P 0 comments

As working class activists, we should share experiences with – and learn from – working class struggles in other places. The ruling class organises worldwide to exploit and dominate our class. So we need to organise resistance to defend our interests everywhere. And we can only benefit from arming ourselves with lessons from different working class movements.

imageImagining the grassroots community - the basic unit of the world commune Aug 03 by Ilan S. 0 comments

It is clear that the multi-level direct democracy of the world commune will be based on the grassroots communities, in whose members' assemblies the decisions will be arrived at and from where the delegates to the higher levels of organizations will be nominated. However, the details that the whole is combined from have been gone into mainly in fiction literature only.

imageEurope & the Bankers Nov 16 by José Antonio Gutiérrez D. 1 comments

All that was needed was a profound economic crisis and a little discontent among the people for Europe's democracies to abandon their liberal facade and show themselves for what they really are: the dictatorship of large Capital. It doesn't matter what the citizens think, the coup d'état in Greece, the nomination of technocrats to the government in Italy and the government in Ireland radio-controlled from Brussels, these are the best proof of the fact that not even in Europe will they hesitate to put aside their democratic formalism is the interests of the 1% are in danger. While the general discontent and popular mobilization grows, what will happen next? [Italiano] [Castellano]

more >>

textPersonal statement on the Michael Schmidt affair: Lucien van der Walt, 11 February 2016 Feb 12 11 comments

Personal statement on the Michael Schmidt affair: Lucien van der Walt, 11 February 2016

imagePublications by Zabalaza Books, March - June 2012 Jun 14 Zabalaza Books [ZACF] 0 comments

All new publications by Zabalaza Books from March till June 2012

imageNew Publications from Zabalaza Books Jan 23 ZB 0 comments

All new publications from Zabalaza Books for the month of January.

textFacebook page of 'Black Flame' reorganised and rebooted Dec 13 0 comments

The Facebook page of 'Black Flame' has been reorganised and rebooted, now carrying regular updates related to the book by Lucien van der Walt and Michael Schmidt...

imageSeptember 2011 publications from Zabalaza Books Nov 14 ZACF 0 comments

All publications from Zabalaza Books for the month of September

more >>
© 2005-2017 Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]